On a factual basis, the Amherst case is one of the most egregious since the Obama administration implemented its policy in 2011. The lawsuit revealed documents that the public almost never gets to see, such as the full investigative file, the transcript of the disciplinary hearing and other material from the campus process. As laid out in the legal complaint and subsequent filings, the controversy over the investigation has focused mostly on a string of texts that the accuser sent the night of the incident. The texts suggest that she had initiated the sexual encounter and that she was in search of a “good lie” to avoid fallout for having hooked up with the accused student, her roommate’s boyfriend. After the judge expressed strong skepticism toward Amherst’s investigation, the two sides came to a settlement.
washingtonpost.com By KC Johnson
College Men: Don’t apply here
Occidental, UVA, Yale, Stanford, Columbia, Harvard, University of Oregon, USC, SMU, UNC, the State of New York, Illinois, Virginia, Minnesota, California and Connecticut. These colleges and states have passed policies and laws that are extremely biased against males. As anti-due process continues, this list increases. Men are preferring Canadian colleges over American colleges. It’s worth your good name, innocence and a successful future for you to go elsewhere.
Pennsylvania State University knows that it’s supposed to “believe the survivor,” but a federal judge just told the public university it has to verify her claimed evidence… John Doe alleged that Penn State refused to require his accuser to provide a written statement with specific allegations throughout the nine-month investigation, preventing him from giving an informed defense. Because the outcome of the proceeding depended on “credibility-based determinations,” the university was wrong to block “almost all” of Doe’s 22 questions for Roe. Judge Brann had particular scorn for Katharina Matic the Title IX investigator.
A Drake University student who was expelled for sexual assault despite evidence he was the party assaulted, received a win in court when a judge refused to dismiss his lawsuit. His accuser admitted during Drake’s campus hearing that she sexually assaulted him, performing oral sex without his consent. Yet she was never punished, while he was expelled based on her accusation.
thefederalist.com By Ashe Schow
The sexual assault charges brought against former Cornell basketball forward Xavier Eaglin ’19 in March 2016 have been dismissed. Although Eaglin no longer faces criminal charges, he will not be able to return to Cornell. After his arrest, Eaglin was dismissed from the basketball team and banned from campus. He spent seven days in jail before he was bailed out by his parents and then returned home. “We are just thankful justice prevailed and that we can start repairing our lives,” said Eaglin’s mother Clara Eaglin.
cornellsun.com By Anna Delwiche
A former member of the Texas A&M University Corps of Cadets filed a federal Title IX lawsuit against the university, alleging A&M officials violated his due-process rights by showing a male gender bias. The suit claims that John Doe was wrongfully accused of sexual misconduct by a female member of the Corps of Cadets and that the Title IX investigative process took place while Doe was hospitalized for treatment of depression without giving him an adequate chance to defend himself.
wacotrib.com By T. Witherspoon
He got her verbal consent “more than four hours” after her last drink. He convinced an investigator she was mentally able to consent. University of Texas-Austin President Greg Fenves thought otherwise, and unilaterally suspended him for five semesters as a rapist. These are the allegations in a troubling federal lawsuit by student “John Doe” against Fenves personally for ignoring explicit UT-Austin policy on consent and devising his own standard – perhaps at the behest of a major donor.
Campus courts don’t necessarily give weight to evidence that favors students accused of rape. Fortunately for those students, real courts aren’t so flagrantly biased. A California Superior Court judge in Los Angeles tossed the state’s case against USC student Mr. Premjee, citing surveillance video from throughout the evening he spent with his female accuser.
University of Cincinnati is desperate to claim the nation’s most unfair campus sexual assault process. In this case, two students met on the Tinder app. The female later claimed the sex wasn’t consensual; the male said it was. At the hearing, neither the accuser nor the Title IX investigator, bothered to appear, denying indirect cross-examination. Panel Chair:’ OK, so the complainant is not here…Respondent, do you have any questions of the Title IX report?’ Accused Student: ‘Well, since she’s not here, I can’t really ask anything of the report.’ The student was found guilty and then sued. UC maintained that its denial of any cross-examination didn’t violate the student’s due process rights.The accused’s attorney Josh Engel faced no skeptical questions from the sixth circuit appeal panel, and made important points about why due process matters.
6th Circuit Summary w Audio Excerpts By KC Johnson
A lawsuit filed by a former Augustana University student who claimed the school unjustly expelled him following a rape accusation has been dismissed. “It was resolved to the satisfaction of the parties” lawyers said, “That is all I can say.” The school’s investigation failed to take into account that his accuser had also accused other students of sexual misconduct, including threatening a prior boyfriend with a false rape allegation. Crucially, the complaint said, Tsuruta was physically incapable of committing the rape as alleged because he had lost his feet in a motor vehicle accident.
argusleader.com By Jonathan Ellis
Two male students accused of sexual misconduct say the University of Texas at Austin and Texas A&M University botched their cases, the latest in a growing backlash against federal requirements that critics say improperly favor campus assault and harassment complainants over the alleged perpetrators.
houstonchronicle.com By Lindsay Ellis